Skip to main content
Artist/Maker
Thomas Nast
(American, born Germany, 1840 - 1902)
Datepublished August 5, 1865
MediumWood engraving on newsprint
DimensionsComposition (a): 13 1/2 in. × 9 in. (34.3 × 22.9 cm)
Composition (b): 13 1/2 × 9 1/8 in. (34.3 × 23.2 cm)
Sheet: 16 3/8 × 22 15/16 in. (41.6 × 58.3 cm)
Credit LineGift of Professor Emeritus Jay Williams, Class of 1954
Object number2019.13.71
Not on view
Description"This double image questions the way African-American war heroes were treated compared to their white contemporaries. In Pardon, white politicians practically worship Columbia, with Andrew Johnson bowing down to ask for her approval. Here Columbia is weighty, larger than life, and bored, compared to Franchise, where she is engaged, passionate, and the same size as the black war hero she points towards and encourages others to respect. Though black soldiers made a huge impact by fighting for the Union, they were not given as much respect as RObert E. Lee and his white counterparts, even though white soldiers often spent less time actually fighting than the African-American soldiers.”
(SOURCE: Susanna White, "Emancipation and Denigration: Thomas Nast Pictures Black America", 2008)
Collections
Additional Details
Alternate Titles
Shall I Trust these Men? And Not this Man?, from "Harper's Weekly"
Exhibition History
2008
Clinton, NY (Emerson Gallery, Hamilton College). "Emancipation and Denigration: Thomas Nast Pictures Black America," January 14, 2008 - April 13, 2008
Clinton, NY (Emerson Gallery, Hamilton College). "Emancipation and Denigration: Thomas Nast Pictures Black America," January 14, 2008 - April 13, 2008
Provenance
2019: Hamilton College (Ruth and Elmer Wellin Museum of Art), by gift of Jay G. Williams.
Published References
Susanna White, EMANCIPATION AND DENIGRATION: THOMAS NAST PICTURES BLACK AMERICA, exh. cat. (Clinton, NY: Emerson Gallery, 2008)
Signature
Signed "Th Nast" in block at lower right composition.
Inscribed
Title typeset beneath images in black ink. Page number "488," publisher, and publication date "August 5, 1863" typeset above composition a in black ink. Publication date, publisher, and page number "489" typeset above composition b at top of the sheet.
Thomas Nast
Date: published March 14, 1874
Medium: Wood engraving on newsprint
Object number: 2019.13.234
Honoré Daumier
Date: published August 31, 1859
Medium: Lithograph on newsprint
Object number: 1986.10
Sénèque Obin
Date: early 1960s
Medium: Oil on masonite
Object number: 1981.13
Thomas Nast
Date: published October 3, 1868
Medium: Wood engraving on newsprint
Object number: 2019.13.103
Thomas Nast
Date: published March 6, 1880
Medium: Wood engraving on newsprint
Object number: 2019.13.502
Thomas Nast
Date: published October 17, 1874
Medium: Wood engraving on newsprint
Object number: 2019.13.255
Dmitri Baltermants
Date: 1941-45 (printed 2003)
Medium: Gelatin silver print
Object number: 2013.5.10
Thomas Nast
Date: published April 1, 1876
Medium: Wood engraving on newsprint
Object number: 2019.13.317